So, the last time we posted on The Walking Dead it was rather, um, sweary on my part. And then
there’s this book I’m writing on Sherlock
(hitting fine bookstores near you in fall 2015) and my deadline was
approaching, and between that and a pile of work that suddenly hit Josh’s desk,
our back-and-forth chats turned into, “Sorry, I meant to send you something
yesterday and I’ll get it to you later today...” “So... by “today” I meant “tomorrow”
and now tomorrow has come and I’ll have it to you later, sorry...” and then it
was sent, and days went by, and the other person was all, “Sorry, I guess we
missed the cut-off because of last night’s episode, should we combine the two?”
“Sure, let’s do that, but first... I have this pile of work and a deadline and
I’ll do my best but...” “OK, two days later, here’s something...” “Great... I’ll
get it to you by the weekend...” “Oh look, the next episode just aired again...”
No end of fun behind the scenes here. But his work let up a
bit, and I officially handed in my manuscript last week (November 19 at
10:33pm) and so there’s been a flurry of catch-up this week.
So here’s what we’ve decided to do: Usually we do a 6-part
back and forth (which, this season, has more often been a 4-part) and instead
what we’ve done is two parts for each episode, covering
5.05 Self
Help (Glenn’s group at the bookstore and sidewalk zombie slurry)
5.06
Consumed (Carol and Daryl and the Beechcraft van)
5.07
Crossed (this past week’s first part of the season finale)
Thanks for bearing with us, and I really do appreciate all
the emails and messages I’ve gotten over the past few weeks asking where our
posts are. ;)
Nikki: So after last
week’s curse-filled rant [just a note that I wrote this three weeks ago] about
the hopelessness of this show, we had a great discussion about how bleak it’s
become versus the episodes that shine like a beacon in the darkness. Rebecca T.
had a lot of great points (go back and check the comments
of the post to read her thoughts). Like I said last week, maybe it’s the
Canadianness in me that can’t accept the whole “there will always be one megalomaniac
to ruin it all” argument, mostly
because the closest we’ve come to apocalypse in my neck of the woods has been
getting dumped with five feet of snow overnight, and that results in every
person in our neighbourhood out on the street helping shovel each other’s
driveways out and even shovelling the street itself to help other cars come and
go — and we also have universal socialized medicine and believe everyone
deserves such a thing, and it’s never been much of an argument here, so maybe
the idea of a hospital with free medical care being an evil nest of evil just
rubbed me the wrong way — but this week’s episode was completely different, and
pretty much summed up all the reasons why I love this show so much despite everything. So I can happily say this post will be
free of swears. ;)
Before I move on, though, I do want to mention I was
chatting about “Slabtown” with my friend Tania, and we were theorizing that
perhaps Carol is faking being on that gurney to sneak her way into the hospital
and break Beth out. Oooh...
But on to this week’s episode. The writing in this outing
was pretty spectacular, and it actually had laughs. No, REALLY, it had laughs.
From Abraham announcing he needs “some ass” before bed and Glenn stuttering
about the TMI-ness of that comment to Eugene creepily watching from the
self-help section of the bookstore — “I consider this a victimless crime that
provides both comfort and distraction” — it was so nice to see some levity in
the midst of the darkness.
And also . . . bookstore. I think I would have waved the
rest of them on their way and just settled in there for the rest of my days. My
heart broke harder seeing the books being ripped apart for kindling than it did
when the zombies got turned into pink mushy stew on the sidewalk. Remember what
the good doctor said about the place of art in this world last week.
And yet it is through the very medium of art — in this case,
television — that the story is being told, and as the writers on Lost did, certain things are dropped
into the framework as shorthand to tell a larger story. Eugene is reading H.G.
Wells’ The Shape of Things to Come at
one point, a book written in 1933 where Wells envisioned history for the next
170 years, imagining a second world war breaking out in 1940 (!!) and lasting
10 years, a dictatorship ultimately rising out of that with religion being
suppressed everywhere, and ultimately that dictatorship dissolving through a
coup and everyone living happily ever after in a utopia as a highly
intelligent, evolved species.
Turns out Eugene’s story that he was going to save the world
was about as realistic as Wells’ solution to humanity’s evils.
The big revelation about Eugene was one that maybe everyone
else saw coming but I certainly didn’t, and my jaw dropped to the ground when
he said it, and then I thought, of course
he doesn’t have the cure. It sounded ridiculous all along, he never gave any
details when anyone would ask, which made no sense because if you have the
cure, don’t you need to have a second copy of it just in case? My husband said
he’d been suspecting this for a few weeks now but said nothing, so perhaps I
was all alone, but Eugene’s big confession, coupled with what it means to
Abraham and the meaning of his life — and everyone who died to keep Eugene and
his Tennessee Top Hat alive — created a climax in an episode that served as
that necessary pause moment we get at least once a season, where we reflect on
where we’ve been and where we’re going.
What were your thoughts, Josh?
Josh: When
Abraham, Eugene and Rosita first came on the scene, I had somewhat mixed
feelings about them. Their corresponding characters in the comics were rather
broadly sketched and kind of underwhelming, and I'll admit I wasn't crazy about
incorporating them into the group. The decision seemed more a matter of
sticking to the source and trying to beef up the ranks after the fall of the
prison than it was a genuine effort to enrich the team. And from the comics, I
knew that Eugene's story was a lie (provided they stayed true to that detail),
so I figured at most their storyline would only serve as a distraction.
What I didn't count on is how much I would like Michael
Cudlitz and Josh McDermitt in these roles. The stereotypical 'redneck'
portrayal can easily come across as a caricature more than an actual human
being, and I don't think that has proven to be the case with Abraham and Eugene
at all. The two of them felt very much the opposing sides of a single coin at
first, with that stark divide between meathead and egghead, but the less
defined parts of their characters have been gradually taking shape, and the
reveals of “Self Help” really snapped them into focus as individuals, finally
bringing to light their histories and motivations in a way that painted them
both as much more human and relatable than before.
For Abraham, the world really ended not when the dead began
to rise. It ended when his willingness to do what he felt was necessary to
protect his family instead drove them away from him. Perhaps the sight of him
beating someone to death with a can of green beans was enough in and of itself
to inspire their fear; it seems more likely that he was already prone to losing
his temper, and the sight of him channeling that rage to murderous effect,
regardless of the premise, only confirmed to his family what they always
suspected him capable. Either way, they ran from his violent nature, right to
their own ends, and Abraham was left to balance both the guilt he feels over
their deaths and the knowledge that the same brutality has now become his most
valuable asset.
It is immediately into the wake of this tragedy that Eugene
stumbles, terrified and desperate, completely inadequate for the business of
staying alive in the new world but savvy enough to know a good opportunity when
he saw it, and more than willing to say and do whatever he needed to maintain
it. He tells a story and renews Abraham's will to live; suddenly his doubt
becomes the staunch mindset and uncompromising attitude we've seen since he
first appeared. Meanwhile, Eugene has done everything in his power to stave the
inevitable moment when the truth comes out – the moment when his usefulness
burns itself out like a candle drowning in its own wax.
Which, of course, isn't true, as Eugene has proven himself
useful in other ways besides hand to hand combat. Anyone who has the kind of
knowledge that can see a fire started with a used battery and a piece of
invisible tape is plenty useful in a post-apocalyptic environment, for any
number of reasons. Survival isn't only about who can stab the most zombie
brains. But Eugene has no self confidence. We're left to assume this is as much
about his life up to the collapse as it is the new state of the world, and he
is keenly aware of the cost, as is proven when he recites the names of all
those friends who were lost to protect him and the fictional idea of a cure.
The guilt has left him haunted, shamed and even more ineffectual than before.
I'm anxious to see how his personality changes if he wakes up from the beating
he received at the hands of Abraham, to see whether he can use this confession
as a springboard to new courage or instead retreats even further into himself.
The Walking Dead has always been terrific at the
action and tension but has sometimes struggled with the character work
necessary to make us feel more than a gut reaction nervousness about the fates
of these people. So far, this season has showed a whole new understanding of
that dynamic, bringing us all the same action while tempering it with emotional
moments that rival anything else on television right now. The writing has never
been better, and I've never felt more engaged and excited as a viewer. “Self
Help” was a perfect example of why the interpersonal relationships are every
bit as important as the zombies.
And this next part was
written several days later, after I managed to miss posting “Self Help” in the
proper week and so we decided to combine the two into one.
Nikki: I agree with you that this season has done
such a great job with the character studies, and its episodes like last week’s
“Consumed,” where we just followed Carol and Daryl, was one such character
study. I LOVED this episode. Not only did it do what it does best, where two
characters are isolated from the rest and we just follow their story to gain a
deeper understanding of them, but it also brought us back around to where we’d
left the story at the end of “Four Walls and a Roof” — where Daryl is calling
into the bushes for someone to come on out now. We speculated last week that
the person he’d be talking to is Noah, and by the end of this episode that’s
exactly who it was. However, I was also thinking, as I said above, that I was
hoping Carol had been faking her injuries to get into the hospital. Wrong.
And let’s just get it out of the way: we all saw that Lost reference, and it was one of those
things where it couldn’t have been by accident. Carol and Daryl see a van
teetering on the edge of a bridge, and what do you do when you see something
like that? Why, good question, Boone, you CLIMB RIGHT IN THAT PUPPY. As soon as
they both got in there I said to my husband, “Cripes, they should have written Beechcraft on the side of the thing...
is this a Lost reference?” (Sadly,
his memory is short, and he had no idea what I was talking about.) And then I said, “Oh
my god is that a Virgin Mary statue on the dash??!!” He remembered that one.
Then kablammo, the van goes down, and they somehow survive the fall (RIP Boone)
and as they were leaving I’m yelling, “Daryl, grab the Virgin Mary statue, you
might want to see what’s inside!!!” Also, when Daryl grabbed that pack of
cigarettes — Morley’s — they were the same brand the Cigarette Smoking Man used
in The X-Files.
My favourite part of this episode involved Carol and Daryl
going to the women’s shelter where Carol spent a night long ago as an abused
wife, running from the man who beat her with her daughter in tow. She revels at
how much she’s changed since then, a woman who ran from danger, then, afraid of
being on her own, she ran back and just took it from a man who betrayed her
trust and love, pushing her daughter back into an environment of violence and
fear. Now her husband is gone, and her daughter is gone, and for all intents
and purposes, that Carol is gone. In her place is the woman who was always
there, just below the surface, but who was never allowed to show her face. But
what has she lost to get here? She addresses the fact that she comes off as
emotionless, but we know that there’s a part of her that can still be hurt, as
we see in the brief flashback to her breaking down when Rick exiled her. It
seemed like she’d been gone for so long, but you realize in this flashback that
he sent her away, and the Governor attacked very soon after, and then she ran
into Tyreese. So she didn’t end up being on her own for very long, but it was
long enough for her to probably think about where she’d ended up, and be on her
own for the first time in a very, very long time. It was within that time she
became the new, stronger version of herself.
What I loved most about this scene is that it was a man and
a woman together, talking. There’s always been a hope that Carol and Daryl
would get together in a romantic way, but their friendship is deeper and
different than that. She falls backwards onto a bed and talks to him, and then
he does exactly the same thing. There are no strings attached, and no
inclination to do anything beyond that. For the first time we see a man and a
woman who just truly care about each other, and there’s nothing more to it than
that. They are both damaged by their pasts, and stronger in their present.
However, where Carol has buried the past in order to move on, Daryl is ready to
stop doing that, as we see when the book about how to treat childhood abuse
falls out of his backpack. Last season he broke down when he was with Beth, and
told her how badly he’d been treated as a child. Now, seeing how strong Carol
has become, he seems ready to finally confront that.
Were you getting Pearl Station flashbacks on this one, too,
Josh? ;)
Joshua: I've been
feeling Lost vibes from this show a lot lately, it seems, from the
opening on Beth's eye in “Slabtown” to the regular flashbacks we're starting to
see. This episode's periodic scenes with Carol recalling moments of isolation
and doubt were just perfect, each one brief and wordless but such deft
touchstones for her state of mind in those situations. There was something
keenly powerful about each one, and I have to give partial credit to the
staging but all the rest to Melissa McBride, whose work has always been amazing
on the show but has really turned it up to 11 this season. The depth of
communication she conveys with just a simple narrowing of her eyes is
phenomenal to me, and I don't think we would find Carol's journey half as
compelling without such a remarkable actor shepherding the portrayal.
Good writing sure doesn't hurt, though, and this season's
been firing bullets throughout. The part that torpedoed me this week was their
run-in with the walker mother and child at the shelter. The whole
shelter-as-backdrop situation was a masterful choice anyway, considering both
Carol and Daryl's respective histories, but that moment in particular really
made it sing for me. Everything about the way it came together was simply
tremendous – with the distant sound first bringing them up from their rest and
on the offensive, then the tension of their search through the darkened
hallways, and then everything shifting when they come upon these two strangers,
faceless through the frosted glass but instantly relatable nonetheless. And
despite Carol's willingness, Daryl then gently holds her back from going in to
'do what had to be done,' only to go back later while she slept and take care
of the job himself. When Carol comes around the corner and finds him gingerly
carrying the bodies to where he's burning them on the roof, the look on her
face held so much warmth and sympathy and affection for this man – someone who
used to be one big raw nerve in a leather vest but is now as important to her
as was once her own daughter, and she more important to him than any family
member he ever had. What an amazing scene.
It's exactly the kind of rich, nuanced material that, more
than flashbacks or anything else, has made me most think of Lost when
watching recent episodes of TWD. The portrayals of these characters has
grown so well-defined that I find myself caring even for cast members as
peripheral as Rosita Espinoza, and our connection to longtime survivors like
Carol and Daryl just continues to deepen. It's why Bob's death was so impactful
a few weeks back, and it will be why the next deaths will hit so much harder
than we're used to feeling here. I have doubts this encounter at the hospital
will go very smoothly, and I think major deaths are inevitable in the coming
finale. And man, it is stressing me out.
Are you getting that same feeling of dread in the pit of
your stomach, Nik?
Nikki: I pretty much always have that dread in my
stomach when I watch my favourite shows. Thank YOU, Joss Whedon, for
demonstrating to showrunners the sheer power of killing off major characters.
Sigh. I agree with you about the zombie mom and child — heartbreaking. We
haven’t seen many zombie children, and Carol hasn’t encountered too many since
her own daughter became one, and she acted quickly to avert the zombifications
of Lizzie and Mika. Considering children would be among the weakest members of
society, you’d think they’d be everywhere . . . and in a real zombie
apocalypse, I suspect they would. They just know that we viewers simply
couldn’t handle seeing that every week. Thank goodness.
And that brings us to “Crossed,” the first part of the
mid-season finale. (I’ll just go on record one more time to say how much I hate
that invented TV term, but anyway...) After paring it down to small character
studies over the past few weeks — Beth in “Slabtown,” then Glenn and Co. in
“Self Help,” then Carol and Daryl in “Consumed” — we start leaping back and
forth between the group of them, showing how they’re all moving in on one
another. Abraham is paralyzed with rage as he sits rigidly on his knees,
unmoving (and dude, when he stands up, his legs will be JELLY), while Eugene
lies unconscious on the ground and Maggie guards both of them, and Glenn,
Rosita, and Tara go fishin’.
As you said above, Eugene may have been lying, but
he knows a LOT of survival techniques that will get them through this, and this
week we learn a new one, where Rosita constructs a water filter with stones and
a piece of her shirt. (I still remember doing this experiment way back in high
school science, and my water was totally muddy at the end of it and I’d clearly
done something wrong. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: I’m going down
early in a zombie apocalypse.) Meanwhile Glenn and Tara discover fish and seem
completely shocked by it. Why? I realize they haven’t exactly been catching
many fish throughout the show, but why would a zombie apocalypse mean the fish
would all die? Or is his surprise a result of this being a murky swampy river
in the middle of nowhere, basically a place one wouldn’t expect to find fish? I
will admit, I’d be wary about eating them. How many zombies are lying along the
bottom of that river (still moving, since zombies don’t have to breathe but they’re
probably stuck in the muck) rotting away while the fish eat pieces of their
flesh? Could the fish be zombified? Ew.
I loved when Maggie came up with the makeshift sunshade for
Eugene, mostly because I had no idea what she was doing at first. Ladder? Blanket?
Is she climbing up onto the roof to sunbathe? That is one smart gal. I feel for
Abraham — we saw the flashbacks to his desperate need for a mission and how he believed he was
actually going to save the world in all of this — but here’s hoping that his
long afternoon of silence might actually make him think everything through for
once and realize that Eugene could still be useful for him.
Meanwhile, over in Slabtown, Rick & Daryl and Company
are having a hell of a time dealing with the cops. My husband called right away
that the dude Noah referred to as “one of the good ones” was actually going to
turn on them, but I’m keen to find out how that’s going to play out. What did
you think about what was going on there?
Joshua: From the
very start, everything about this rescue mission tastes sour to me. As he's
making his initial plan, Rick seems far overconfident about the ease with which
they can liberate their friends and minimize bloodshed. Daryl and Tyrese both
call him out on it, and the plot complicates further with their revised plan to
trade hostages. The shot-in-the-air ploy they use to attract attention works
well, but they underestimate Dawn's cops, who have a backup man watching from
nearby.
It's a mistake that almost costs them both their leverage
and Daryl, who narrowly escapes a violent death at the hands of meat slab
Licari (and Licari who in turn narrowly escapes a gunshot head at the hands of
Rick, thanks to Daryl's quick reasoning). And then, after their initial
underestimation, THEY DO IT AGAIN by trusting their three prisoners' integrity,
including full faith in their information about Dawn and the situation at
Grady. To boot, Sasha's own struggles with the weight of the murder she
committed inspire her to isolate herself with one of them in an attempt to
'help' him and instead winds up bleeding on the floor. Now Lamson is on the
run, headed back toward the hospital to fill Dawn in on their plans, ensuring
they've lost their best bargaining chip and the element of surprise, not to mention
possibly losing Sasha from active duty (which will surely mean losing Tyrese,
too). The odds are narrowing, and not in their favor.
But maybe things aren't quite as they seem, after all. Maybe
Lamson was actually on the level, and he's now headed back to marshal his own
troops, planning to use RickCo's posse as the distraction he needs to mount the
takeover he's been planning all along. Anything could happen at this point, and
that's the beauty of this setup. Next week's half-finale begins with a lot of
pieces in motion, and right now we have no idea what to expect. Will these
plots converge again, with perhaps others like Michonne (or maybe even Morgan)
showing up at the hospital just in time to turn the tide? Or will this prove to
be another tragedy from which they might emerge, but only smaller in number and
permanently scarred?
In the immortal words of Han Solo, I've got a bad feeling
about this.
We've blown through three episodes of recap in very short
order, Nikki. I know that's somewhat out of necessity because we've managed to
fall so far behind in recent weeks (and apologies to the steady readership for
what I promise couldn't be avoided), but I don't want to be overly hasty,
either, particularly considering the high quality of this run of episodes. Was
there anything else we've missed that you wanted to discuss before we wrap it
up?
Nikki: I was glad to see the hospital again; even
though that, technically, was our last post on The Walking Dead, it was also four weeks ago now, and it was nice
to see the doctor again. I don’t know what Dawn is playing at by
giving Beth the key to the drug cabinet. The doctor insinuated that Beth is
being played, but Beth goes along with it anyway. But then again, Noah had said
that Lamson was on the level and he appears to have betrayed Sasha. I think it’ll
be fascinating if, in the final episode, we find out the bad guys might
actually be the good guys, and vice versa, and everyone has to question which
side they’ve aligned themselves with. That’s the sort of thing The Walking Dead is really good at
exploring.
But then again, as you say, it’s a mid-season finale. And
bad things always happen in those
episodes. Let’s brace ourselves... something tells me our people are not going
to come out intact.
Thanks for bearing with us everyone, and again, sorry for the wait.